Bring Stoley's Bottle to "Sea Wolf" MacKinley in Booty Bay.
Thanks again for your help, <name>. Here's a bottle of Steamwheedle bilge rum. Take it to MacKinley and he can finally put to rest his crazy beliefs about Booty Bay booze.
Did Stoley cough up my booze?
Hm, let's try this...
I can't believe it! This stuff is... terrible! That's great!
Well I guess Stoley can keep the money he owes me. He's true to his word about Steamwheedle bilge rum. That stuff is as thick as gravel and burns like lava!